About Papay Agency

The Papay Insurance Agency specializes in Home, Auto, Condo, Renters, Umbrella, Motorcycle, Flood, Boat, ATV, Off-Road, Business and Life insurance policies.

5+

Years in business

Papay Insurance Agency is located in the Riverwalk Commons shopping center in Okatie, SC.

Landon Papay, Owner of Papay Insurance Agency, is a licensed insurance agent in the states of Georgia and South Carolina. Papay Agency specializes in providing a unique experience for coastal markets like Bluffton, Okatie, Hardeeville, Hilton Head, Beaufort, Charleston and the Coastal Empire of Georgia.

Anytime Cancellation Policy

Save Money with Bundles

Our Mission: We exist to protect your property, future and peace of mind.

We Have A Great History

Established the Papay Insurance Agency

The Papay Agency, specializing in Home, Auto, Condo, Renters, Motorcycle, Boat, ATV, Business and Life insurance policies, opened its doors in Okatie, SC on December 1, 2018.

2019

Hosted Fingerprint ID Scans Events for Children

Received Allstate National Conference Award recognizing the Papay Agency for their high standards of commitment to customers & contribution to the local community.

Received Allstate Honor Ring Award, highlighting the top 16% of Allstate Agencies in the country.

2020

Received Allstate National Conference Award recognizing the Papay Agency for their high standards of commitment to customers & contribution to the local community.

Received Allstate Honor Ring Award, highlighting the top 16% of Allstate Agencies in the country.

2021

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agent, Landon Papay

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agency

Received Allstate Honor Ring Award, highlighting the top 16% of Allstate Agencies in the country.

2022

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agent, Landon Papay

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agency

Received Allstate National Summit Award, highlighting the top 8% of Allstate Agencies in the country.

Received Allstate Honor Ring Award, highlighting the top 16% of Allstate Agencies in the country.

2023

Designated as a Pinnacle Elite Allstate Insurance Agency, The Papay Agency is recognized as being among the top 3% of Allstate Insurance Agencies in the U.S.

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agent, Landon Papay

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agency

Expanded our Sales Office in 2023 to better serve our clients.

2024

Top 8% of Allstate Insurance agencies nationwide

#1 spot for growing to scale in North Carolina and South Carolina

Received Allstate National Summit Award, highlighting the top 8% of Allstate Agencies in the country

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agent, Landon Papay

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agency

Celebrated 6 Years of service in the Lowcountry on December 1st.

2025

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agent, Landon Papay

Won Best of Bluffton - Best Insurance Agency

What Our Customers Say About Papay Insurance Agency

Landon was extremely personable and quick! We made an appt and I got my quote the same day! He cared about my family and my needs and he worked his best in an honest manor. Life, home, auto, umbrella... he’s your guy!

Taylor L.

- Life, Home & Auto Insurance Customer

The Papay Insurance Team is very helpful and professional in their work. Gilda and Asia have come through for me and I am glad to know they are there working with Landon to give my family the best insurance service we can get.

Deborah P.

- Home and Auto Insurance Customer

Gilda Rogers was very pleasant, personable, and professional. She made the process extremely easy and took care of my policy needs at a reasonable and competitive rate. I am so glad I was referred to her and look forward to having her as my new agent.

Diane G.

- Home Insurance Customer

Our Team

At Papay Insurance, our strength comes from the people behind the policies. Our dedicated team is here to guide you with personalized service, local expertise, and a commitment to protecting what matters most. We believe insurance should feel less complicated and more supportive, and that’s why our agents and staff go above and beyond for every client. We’re proud to serve a diverse community, offering bilingual support so every client feels confident and understood.

MEET OUR TEAM